Teen Murders Parents and Lives with dead Bodies for Two Weeks in Oak Creek, Wisconsin
The quiet suburban streets of Waukesha, Wisconsin, often echo with the sounds of everyday life – children playing, cars commuting, and neighbors chatting. But in late February 2025, an unsettling silence began to emanate from a home, a silence that would soon be shattered by a discovery so horrific it would send shockwaves through the community and beyond. What began as a routine welfare check unveiled a scene of unimaginable tragedy: two adults found deceased, and their teenage son allegedly living in the same residence for over a week .
The grim sequence of events began to unfold when Judith Mayer, the mother of Donald Mayer, grew increasingly concerned about her lack of contact with her son since February 23rd. Adding to her worries were a series of unsettling text messages she had received from his phone . Simultaneously, a noticeable absence at Waukesha West High School raised alarms. Seventeen-year-old Nikita Casap had been uncharacteristically absent for two weeks, a stark contrast to his previous record of perfect attendance . These converging concerns prompted a call to the authorities, setting in motion an investigation that would reveal a chilling domestic tragedy .
On February 28th, 2025, Waukesha County Sheriff's deputies arrived at the residence to conduct a welfare check. Inside, they made a series of disturbing discoveries. The body of Tatiana Casap, 35, was found in a first-floor hallway, covered with towels and a blanket. Decomposition was evident, and investigators noted what appeared to be an exit wound on her back near her right shoulder, along with a possible bullet hole in the adjacent wall . Later, a second body was found in a first-floor office. This was identified as 51-year-old Donald Mayer, Tatiana's husband and Nikita's stepfather. His body was covered by a pile of clothing, and he had sustained an obvious wound to the back of his head . The scene painted a picture of violence and concealment within the confines of a family home.
The deceased were identified as Tatiana Casap and Donald Mayer . Tatiana, at 35, was the mother of the accused, Nikita Casap. Donald, 51, was her husband and Nikita's stepfather . The individual at the center of this tragedy is 17-year-old Nikita Casap . As the son and stepson of the victims, his alleged involvement has sent ripples of disbelief and sorrow through their family and the wider community . The age of the accused, still a minor, adds a layer of profound disquiet to the already grim circumstances, prompting questions about what could have led to such a devastating outcome .
The timeline pieced together by investigators suggests a prolonged and deeply unsettling period following the deaths. While the exact date the lives of Tatiana and Donald were taken is under investigation, prosecutors indicated in court that they believe the homicides occurred around February 11th . Nikita Casap was apprehended in Kansas on February 28th . This suggests that the teenager potentially lived in the Waukesha home with the bodies of his mother and stepfather for approximately 12 to 13 days before leaving the state . A neighbor reported seeing Nikita driving his stepfather's car alone on February 23rd, further solidifying the timeline of his presence in the vicinity after the likely date of the killings . Cell phone location data corroborated his departure from the Waukesha area on February 24th . The extended period between the alleged crime and the discovery underscores the potential for a calculated effort to conceal the deaths, adding a disturbing dimension to the tragedy.
The investigation has begun to shed light on the alleged method of the killings and the evidence gathered. Tatiana Casap was found to have suffered gunshot wounds to her neck and torso, while Donald Mayer sustained a fatal gunshot wound to the head . A Smith & Wesson .357 Magnum firearm, owned by Donald Mayer, was missing from the residence but later recovered from the car Nikita Casap was driving in Kansas . Spent shell casings were also found in the vehicle . These details strongly suggest that a firearm was used in both deaths, and the recovery of Mayer's gun in Nikita's possession is a significant piece of evidence . As of the initial reports, a definitive motive for the alleged crimes has not been publicly disclosed . However, the fact that Nikita allegedly took his parents' car, $14,000 in cash, and attempted to flee the state points towards a possible awareness of wrongdoing and an attempt to evade the consequences . Furthermore, reports indicate that Nikita engaged in transactions using a bitcoin machine and communicated with individuals overseas via an app in Russian or Romanian, prompting the involvement of the FBI for translation . These actions could potentially reveal further details about his state of mind and any plans he might have had following the deaths.
The legal proceedings against Nikita Casap are underway. He was initially charged with operating a vehicle without the owner's consent and theft of movable property, specifically his stepfather's car and the handgun . These initial charges allowed authorities to detain him following his arrest in Kansas and his subsequent extradition back to Wisconsin . Nikita made his first court appearance in Waukesha County on Wednesday, March 12th, 2025, where a $250,000 bond was set . While formal charges directly related to the deaths of Tatiana Casap and Donald Mayer had not been filed at that time, prosecutors explicitly stated their intention to file charges of first-degree intentional homicide in the near future . As of March 14th, 2025, Nikita Casap was booked into the Waukesha County Jail . A preliminary hearing in the case is scheduled for March 24th, a date when it is anticipated that the additional, more serious charges connected to the homicides will be formally presented . The legal process is expected to be lengthy and complex as the investigation continues to unfold.
This report relies on factual information obtained from reputable news sources. The details presented are based on initial reports and court documents available as of March 15th, 2025. Sources used in this article are cited according to the American Psychological Association (APA) 7th Edition style.
Conclusion
The unfolding events in Waukesha represent a profound tragedy that has deeply affected the local community. The allegations against a 17-year-old for the deaths of his mother and stepfather, coupled with the disturbing detail of him allegedly living in the same home for an extended period, paint a grim picture of domestic horror. While the motive behind the alleged crimes remains unclear, the ongoing investigation and legal proceedings will likely reveal more information in the coming weeks and months. The community now grapples with the shock and sorrow of this unthinkable event, awaiting further developments in the pursuit of justice for Tatiana Casap and Donald Mayer.
Wisconsin Crime Videos
